Posts tagged Dalai Lama

More on Detained Pilgrims

Tibetan pilgrims returning from the Kalachakra initiation in India at the beginning of January have faced various difficulties (see previous posts here and here). Now, it seems that many of them are still in detention and subjected to political reeducation. Apparently, many of the pilgrims are government officials. Tendar Tsering reports for Phayul:

“The Chinese government has warned Tibetan officials in Chinese occupied Tibet of serious actions and harsh punishments if they failed to return home before February 15,” Kalsang Gyaltsen, a Member of the Tibetan Parliament-in-Exile said.

According to Human Rights Watch this may be the first time since the 1970 that such a large number of lay people are being detained.
Between 7,000 and 8,000 pilgrims had received the permission to leave the country for Nepal and the authorities must clearly have known where they were heading for. Most seem to have had passports and valid Nepalese visas.

A number of them also traveled directly to India using visas issued by India, indicating that on this occasion the Chinese authorities had not placed restrictions on travel to India in Tibetans’ passports, as in the past. There is no known regulation banning Tibetans from attending the teachings, and the returnees undergoing re-education have not been accused of any crime, such as carrying illicit documents or crossing the Chinese border without permission.
There are no reports so far that any of the estimated 700 ethnic Chinese from China who attended the Dalai Lama’s teachings in Bihar have been detained on their return to China, suggesting that the detainees are being selected because of their ethnicity.

Posted in Border Review | Also tagged , , | Leave a comment

Dharamshala and Waco

Michael Martina (Reuters) comments on a People’s Daily article about the Dalai Lama’s stance that he will not be reborn in the PRC if Tibet is not free, and that there would be options to choose his future successor other than the traditional system of finding a reincarnation.

“The Dalai Lama not only is attempting to bury long established historical tenets of Tibetan Buddhism with him when he dies, but is adding another criminal charge to his teachings of separatism, which damages Tibet and Buddhism,” the People’s Daily, the mouthpiece of the ruling Communist Party, said in a commentary. [...] The Dalai Lama’s goal in denouncing the Chinese government’s right to supervise reincarnation is to preserve his clique’s grasp on the symbol of the next reincarnation and serve his political separatist aims,” the commentary said.

To help make its point, the commentary borrowed from recent American history, when U.S. federal agents raided the headquarters of David Koresh’s Branch Davidian religious sect in Waco, Texas, amid allegations of child abuse, statutory rape and underage marriage.
“At that time, David Koresh called himself Jesus, ensnared large groups of followers, publicly opposed national law, and in 1993 he was eliminated by federal agents who even used tanks,” the paper said.

While the US crushes a religious movement with military force, the People’s Republic is concerned about safeguarding traditional Tibetan religious culture. This argument, regardless of its accuracy or validity, points to the fact how central the notion of cultural heritage has become in Party discourse on Tibet (see for example this White Paper on the preservation and development of Tibetan culture). In the West, of course, allegations against the Dalai Lama for damaging Tibetan Buddhism are read as crude propaganda.

What both sides fail to grasp is the extent to which the worldly power of reincarnated Lama lineages has always been a deeply political and contested affair. In the Tibetan Buddhist regions of Russia, for example, the system of reincarnation has long been replaced by election. The Party State’s quest to separate religion from politics and portray reincarnation as a matter of authentic “intangible cultural heritage” gives the debate about Tibet a new twist – albeit a no less political one.

Posted in Border Review | Also tagged , , , | Leave a comment